“Comments”
I say use it, it’s fun.
You sound like a business woman. Although you’re not a fan of the series, your fans might be. I would would go with a mixture of buttons including the Twilight inspired ones. Personally, if I were to get one of your buttons, I’d go with “Got Gothic?” or even “Got Goth?” 
Okay Leslie, you know I am a total HATER! I say this with all earnestness…DON’T DO IT! Mostly cause it doesn’t make sense. Don’t pit your Hero and Heroine against each other. Go with the Got Gothic? one. It makes more sense. Or maybe something like…Not just another fairytale or Got Beauty? or Got Beast? or…well anything but that Twilight business. 
And here’s the thing; Team X & Team Y have been around a long time. It’s just that the Jacob/Edward thing has popularized it for this generation. Go ahead, use it.
